Stories of the Tunes – Colonel Maclean of Ardgour


Pipe Major John McLellan DCM, Dunoon is recognised as a composer of many fine tunes. One of them, the 2/4 march, Colonel Maclean of Ardgour, he named for someone with whom he served in the same regiment during the First World War. The tune can be found in Volume 2 of Pipe Major Angus MacDonald, M.B.E.’s collection, The Pipe Music Of The Clan Maclean, the Scots Guards (volume 3), The Bagpipe Music Of John McLellan and The Argyll And Sutherland Highlanders Pipe Music Book Collection. Jim McGillivray also has it on his website.

However, despite being widely available, the tune is not heard very often. In discussing the man behind the tune, we include a tale of how war can sometimes have an unusual twist of fate:

By Iain Thornber

The First World War, or the Great War, as it became known, started at Mons in Belgium in 1914. When it ended four years later, it had been one of the bloodiest conflicts in the history of the human race. Ten million military personnel are estimated to have died in the trenches and on the battlefields when the veneer of civilisation collapsed in the quicksand of sucking mud, dysentery and slaughter.

Yet, despite the unspeakable carnage, acts of kindness and decency did happen on both sides. Compassion is a quality that is usually hard to come by in times of war. It’s even harder to show it to the enemy. After all, how can you be nice to someone who might actively have tried to kill you? Of all the recent events commemorating the centenary of the ending of the Great War, probably the most well known is the unofficial Christmas Truce of 1914 when both sides were able to remember that there were bigger, more important things, than killing. The ceasefire lasted well past Christmas and even into 1915. It began with singing that drifted out over the debris-strewn waste of No Man’s Land, the swapping of small gifts of food and cigarettes and a game of football. It also allowed many soldiers to bury their fallen comrades.

Alexander 16th Chief of Ardgour (second left with the cromach) with Sir Fitzroy Maclean, 27th Chief of the Clan Maclean at Duart in 1912.

There is another equally touching story closer to home but little known outside the family concerned. It began in August 1912 at Duart on the island of Mull when MacLeans from all over the world gathered to celebrate the castle’s return to the family after 200 years.  Among the 700 people present were Alexander John Hew Maclean (1880-1930), the 16th laird and chief of Ardgour and a high-ranking officer in the German army whose family, the Macleans of Coll, had gone out there as mercenaries in the 1600s.

Two years after the Duart celebrations, Great Britain and Germany were at war. Alexander Maclean, enlisted in his local regiment, the 8th Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders (A&SH). A few weeks after arriving in France in August 1914 with the 2nd Battalion, he fought at Le Cateau where over 8,000 British soldiers died, including 44 men of the A&SH, attempting to halt the German advance after the Battle of Mons. Alexander, by now a Captain, was officially reported missing and not heard of until early October when his London bankers notified his family at Ardgour that a cheque, signed a fortnight before, had just come in suggesting he might have captured and was unharmed. On the November 24, 1914, confirmation of his incarceration came in a postcard from Torgau, a prison of war (POW) camp on the banks of the Elbe in north western Saxony, addressed to Thomas Maclean, ferry master and tenant of the Nether Lochaber Hotel, to whom he was related through the Macleans of Inverscaddle, now called Conaglen.

“I am in good health but wish above all that I was back with the regiment. This is a dreadful waste of time. I got one good day only, a fine fight with a fine enemy. Was very lucky not to be hit, but unlucky not to get away. I look forward so much to returning to my best friends and seeing you all again. Beannachd [Blessing] ARDGOUR.”

By February 1916, Alexander was in Blankenburg prison near Berlin, whose commandant, by a curious twists of fate, was Rittmeister Archibald Maclean von Czerbienczin whose company he had enjoyed at Duart in 1912. A second postcard to Thomas Maclean that year contained a hint of things to come:

“My dear Thomas your letter and card were most welcome, but I could have wished the label [advertising fine old Highland whisky] had been stuck onto a bottle instead of a post card. However, it is a good view of the ferry [Corran] which I am glad to have up on the wall. I would write oftener if there was anything to say and did write to you once when I had a bit of news to give you.

“But this life is wanting in interest. I was glad to get your letter telling me [that] the news you gave the best friends a man ever had, pleased them. May the time come soon when I shall bring home someone who will please them more. My health and spirits could not be better under the circumstances but as there seems no hope of a return to the front, I live in the future for a return home. God bless you and yours and all at Ardgour.”

That “someone” was the Hon. Muriel Burns, younger daughter of Lord and Lady Inverclyde of Castle Weymss, whom he met in 1908. Muriel had been a nurse at the Front before joining the Voluntary Aid Detachment (VAD), a voluntary unit of civilians providing nursing care for military personnel. The engagement was announced on August 17, 1918, by which time Muriel was at The New Hospital at the Hague in neutral Holland, prompting Alexander to ask his kinsman and captor, Rittmeister Archibald Maclean, if he would release him on parole for two weeks to allow him to get married. Knowing him as a man of honour who would not break his word, the commandant agreed.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is Maclean-wedding-1918-1024x1016.jpg
Capt Alexander and the Hon Mrs Maclean of Ardgour following their marriage at the Hague in 1918 when Alexander was still a POW.

The marriage was celebrated from the British Legation at The Hague on Thursday, September 5, 1918. A civil ceremony, which was and still is necessary in Holland, took place in the town hall. The witnesses were Pieter Maclean Pont, representing an old Dutch branch of the Clan Maclean, and Thomas Dale, the director in Holland of Kodak Ltd. The Rev. Herbert Ratford, chaplain to the Legation, officiated at the religious service at the Anglican Church of St John and St Philip. As the couple left the church, ten regimental pipers played them to their carriage to the tune of Highland Wedding. The brief honeymoon was spent sailing on the Frisian Lakes [in the north of the Netherlands]. There were many wedding gifts including a silver jug from Her Royal Highness Princess Louise, Duchess of Argyll and Honorary Colonel-in-Chief of the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is Col-Maclean-of-Ardgour-from-John-MacColl-book-1024x987.jpg
Click to enlarge.

Two months after the wedding, Alexander was repatriated and reunited with his regiment and ordered to join the staff at Scottish Command Headquarters. He left the regular army in 1922 and was promoted Lieutenant colonel (Lt Col) on the Reserve of Officers in 1924. He and Muriel returned to Ardgour where they raised five daughters. Alexander died very suddenly in 1930 of a heart attack outside Kiel House, Ardgour, aged 50. Muriel passed away in 1976. On the death of her father, their eldest daughter, Catriona, became the 17th laird, and chief of Ardgour and was succeeded by her nephew Robin Torrie, the present chief, who changed his name to Maclean of Ardgour. 

Alexander’s funeral, which took place in front of Ardgour House on a lovely May day in 1930, was attended by hundreds of mourners and several detachments of the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders. The coffin was taken to the old family burying ground at Cill Mhaodain proceeded by a piper playing Lochaber No More and carried by relays of estate staff. The pall bearers were: Lord Inverclyde; Major Hector Maclean Younger of Duart; Mr Dugald MacDonald, oldest employee on the estate, Mr Alexander Maclean, oldest tenant; Cameron of Lochiel; the Duke of  Argyll; Commander H. Maclean and the Earl of Morton, proprietor of Conaglen Estate which had been purchased from the Macleans.

The deceased was described in the eulogy as an officer and a gentlemen in every sense of the term, and was loved and respected by every officer and man of the 8th Argylls. Pipe Major John McLellan DCM, Dunoon, who had served with him, later composed the pipe tune, Colonel Maclean of Ardgour.

• Listen to Dan Nevans, pictured, playing the tune, Colonel Maclean of Ardgour.

* This article first appeared in the Oban Times of September 6, 2018. Reproduced with permission.